Reviewer Guidelines
Peer review is essential to maintaining the integrity of the scientific record and the quality of published research. The reviewer's role is to provide constructive, unbiased, and timely feedback that helps authors improve their work and assists the editors in making informed decisions.
Review Model
JASE uses single-anonymized (single-blind) peer review. Reviewers know the authors’ identities, but authors are not told who reviewed their manuscript. Please maintain this confidentiality.
Evaluation Criteria
- Originality and Significance: Does the manuscript contribute new knowledge, offer a novel perspective, or address an important gap? Is it within the journal’s scope?
- Methodological Rigor: Is the research design appropriate? Are methods, data collection, and analysis robust, transparent, and clearly described? Are limitations acknowledged?
- Clarity and Structure: Is the manuscript well organized? Are arguments logical and language clear? Are tables and figures appropriate and self-explanatory?
- Ethical Compliance: Does the study follow ethical standards for human/animal subjects, informed consent, and data integrity? Are potential conflicts of interest disclosed?
- References: Are citations relevant, current, and sufficient? Are key works in the field acknowledged?
Reviewer Responsibilities
- Confidentiality: Treat the manuscript and all associated data as confidential. Do not share, retain, or use the work before publication.
- Objectivity: Provide professional, unbiased comments. Personal criticism of authors is inappropriate.
- Conflict of Interest: Disclose any financial, personal, or professional conflict to the editor immediately and decline the review if necessary.
- Timeliness: Complete the review within the agreed timeframe. If you need an extension, notify the editorial office as soon as possible.
- Constructive Feedback: Give specific, actionable comments. Explain your reasoning and suggest improvements where possible. Separate major concerns from minor issues.
- Ethical Concerns: If you suspect plagiarism, duplicate submission, data fabrication, or other ethical issues, report it confidentially to the editor.
- Use of AI: Do not upload the manuscript to AI tools or use AI to generate review comments. If you use AI-assisted language editing for your own comments, disclose this to the editor.
How to Structure Your Review
A useful review often includes:
- A brief summary of the manuscript and its main claims.
- Major comments: key strengths, weaknesses, and required revisions.
- Minor comments: specific issues with clarity, references, tables, or figures.
- A clear recommendation.
Recommendation Options
- Accept: Ready for publication as is (or with only editorial corrections).
- Minor Revision: Small changes required; no further external review normally needed.
- Major Revision: Substantial improvements required, followed by another round of review.
- Reject: Not suitable for publication in JASE.

