Publication Policies


These policies apply to all authors, reviewers, editors, and readers of the Journal of Applied Studies in Education (JASE). The journal follows the Core Practices of the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE). Where this document is silent, the applicable COPE guidelines and flowcharts govern. Questions about these policies may be directed to the editorial office at editor@jaseweb.org.

1. Peer Review Policy

1.1 Initial screening

Every submission is checked by the editorial office for fit with the journal's scope, completeness of the submission package, including author names, affiliations, and contact details, language quality, and the presence of required research-ethics documentation. A submission that fails these checks may be returned to the author without external review. All manuscripts are screened for text similarity before review and again before acceptance.

1.2 Review model

Original research articles are reviewed under a single-anonymised (single-blind) model: reviewers are aware of the authors' identities, but the authors are not told who reviewed their manuscript. Because reviewers know who the authors are, they are asked to judge the work solely on its merits and to disregard the authors' identity, institution, or country. Each manuscript is evaluated by at least two independent reviewers with relevant expertise. Additional reviewers, including a statistical or methodological reviewer, may be appointed at the discretion of the handling editor.

1.3 Reviewer selection and conduct

Reviewers are selected on the basis of subject expertise and the absence of competing interests. Reviewers must treat manuscripts as confidential documents; must not share, cite, or discuss their content before publication; must not delegate a review to a third party; and must not upload manuscript content into publicly accessible generative AI tools (see section 9).

1.4 Review criteria

Reviewers are asked to assess: originality and contribution to educational research or practice; the soundness of the research question, design, and methods; the quality of analysis and interpretation; adherence to reporting standards and to the ethical requirements set out in section 7; the adequacy of citation of prior work; and the clarity of argument and presentation. Reviewers recommend one of the following: accept; accept subject to minor revisions; reconsider after major revisions; reject. Reviewers' recommendations are advisory; the decision rests with the handling editor or the Editor-in-Chief.

1.5 Decisions and revision

Authors receive the editorial decision together with the reviewers' reports, anonymised. Revised manuscripts may be returned for further evaluation on one or more occasions. Authors are asked to submit a point-by-point response to each reviewer's comments together with every revision.

1.6 Timelines

The journal aims to reach a first decision within four weeks of submission and to publish accepted articles within four weeks of acceptance. These targets are indicative; delays can arise from difficulty in securing suitable reviewers or from the need to investigate ethical concerns.

1.7 Confidentiality and records

Editorial correspondence, reviewer identities, and review reports are confidential. Editorial records are retained for five years.

2. Authorship and Contributorship

2.1 Authorship criteria

In line with COPE guidance on authorship and contributorship, authorship requires all four of the following:

  • substantial contribution to the conception or design of the work, or to the acquisition, analysis, or interpretation of data for the work;
  • drafting the work, or revising it critically for important intellectual content;
  • final approval of the version to be published;
  • agreement to be accountable for all aspects of the work, ensuring that questions relating to its accuracy or integrity are appropriately investigated and resolved.

All four conditions must be met. Individuals meeting only some of these criteria should be acknowledged rather than listed as authors. Acquisition of funding, collection of data, technical support, or general supervision alone does not constitute authorship.

2.2 Contribution statements

Authors are encouraged to provide an individual contribution statement at submission, using the CRediT taxonomy or a comparable scheme.

2.3 Corresponding author

The corresponding author acts on behalf of all co-authors. They are responsible for ensuring that all authors have approved the submitted and final versions, for managing correspondence with the journal, and for obtaining permission to reproduce any third-party material.

2.4 Changes to authorship

Requests to add, remove, or reorder authors must be submitted in writing by the corresponding author, must be signed by all authors including any person to be added or removed, and must state the reason for the change. Requests made after acceptance require editorial approval and are decided in accordance with the COPE flowcharts. Post-publication changes of authorship are considered only in exceptional circumstances and are implemented through a publicly available correction notice.

2.5 Authorship disputes

The journal does not adjudicate disputes about authorship or contribution. Where authors cannot resolve such a dispute themselves, the matter is referred to their institution or employer. Consideration or publication may be suspended until the dispute is resolved.

2.6 Non-human tools

AI tools, including generative language models, do not meet the requirements for authorship and must never be listed or cited as authors (see section 9).

3. Plagiarism, Text Recycling and Research Misconduct

3.1 Similarity screening

All manuscripts are screened for text similarity using Crossref Similarity Check (powered by iThenticate) at submission and again before acceptance. Similarity reports are interpreted qualitatively by the editorial office and the handling editor; no single percentage is decisive.

3.2 Plagiarism

Reproduction of another person's text, ideas, data, images, or arguments without proper attribution, whether or not the source is published in English, constitutes misconduct.

3.3 Text recycling

Reuse of the authors' own previously published wording may be acceptable in limited amounts, principally in the description of methods or background, provided the source is cited. Substantive reuse of previously published text without citation is not acceptable.

3.4 Other forms of misconduct

The following are also regarded as misconduct: fabrication or falsification of data; undisclosed duplicate submission or redundant publication; inappropriate manipulation of images; manipulation of citations; manipulation of the peer review process, including suggesting fabricated reviewers or impersonating a suggested reviewer; and failure to disclose a competing interest.

3.5 Handling of suspected misconduct

Suspected misconduct is handled in accordance with the COPE guidelines and flowcharts. The journal may request the underlying data, contact the authors' institution, request a formal institutional investigation, publish an expression of concern, or retract the article, as appropriate. Where an institutional investigation concludes, the journal acts on its findings.

4. Prior Publication, Preprints and Multiple Submissions

4.1 Originality requirement

Original research articles must not have been published previously in a peer-reviewed venue and must not be under consideration by any other journal at the time of submission.

4.2 Preprints

The journal accepts submissions previously posted as preprints on a recognised server, for example EdArXiv, SocArXiv, PsyArXiv, or SSRN. The preprint must be disclosed at submission and its DOI or URL supplied. After publication, authors are asked to update the preprint record with a link to the version of record.

4.3 Theses and dissertations

Work derived from a thesis or dissertation is acceptable provided it has not been published elsewhere in copyrighted form, is presented and framed as a journal article, and cites the thesis.

4.4 Conference materials

Presentation of findings at a conference, or publication of a conference abstract, does not constitute prior publication, provided the abstract is cited in the manuscript.

4.5 Concurrent submission and duplicate publication

Submitting the same manuscript to more than one journal simultaneously, or publishing substantially the same work in more than one venue without the informed consent of all editors concerned, is misconduct and may result in retraction.

4.6 Secondary publication

Secondary publication, including translated articles, is governed by section 5.

5. Policy on Translated Articles (Secondary Publication)

5.1 Scope

The journal publishes English translations of articles originally published in another language, following the COPE guidance on secondary publication, in order to make research that would otherwise remain inaccessible to an English-language readership available to a wider audience.

5.2 Selection

Translated articles are identified by the editorial board, or may be proposed to the editorial board by the original author(s), on the basis of the original work's scholarly contribution and its relevance to an international readership.

5.3 Conditions for publication

A translated article may be published only where all of the following are satisfied:

  • written permission to publish the English translation has been obtained from the original publisher or other copyright holder and from the original author(s), and a copy of that permission is retained by the journal;
  • the original article was itself subject to independent peer review;
  • the original source is fully acknowledged on the article page, including the complete citation, the DOI or URL of the original article, and the original publisher's copyright notice;
  • the translation has been assessed by the editorial team for accuracy, completeness, and scholarly integrity;
  • the substance of the work has not been altered; no data have been added, removed, or reinterpreted.

5.4 Presentation

In line with COPE guidance, a translated article is not presented as new primary research. Each translated article carries a visible note identifying the original article as the version of record, together with a link to it and the date of original publication.

5.5 Translation arrangements

Authors may provide their own English translation, or may ask the journal to arrange one. Where the journal arranges the translation, the author(s) review and approve the final translated text before publication. Any use of machine translation or generative AI tools must comply with section 9.

5.6 Licensing

The licence applied to a translated article follows the licence of the original work and the terms of the permission granted by the original publisher. It may therefore differ from the licence applied to original articles, as set out in section 12.

6. Competing Interests and Funding Disclosure

6.1 Definition

A competing interest exists where financial, personal, academic, political, religious, or other considerations could reasonably be perceived to compromise, or appear to compromise, the objectivity of an author, reviewer, or editor.

6.2 Authors

All authors must disclose relationships and activities that could have influenced the work during the three years preceding submission. These include, but are not limited to: employment and consultancies; research grants and honoraria; paid expert testimony; patents and royalties; stock or shareholdings; membership of advisory boards; and non-financial interests such as personal relationships, ideological commitments, or competing theoretical positions. Where no competing interest exists, the manuscript must state this explicitly. The role of the funder, if any, in study design, data collection, analysis, interpretation, writing, and the decision to submit must be stated, including where the funder had no such role.

6.3 Reviewers and editors

Reviewers must decline an invitation, or disclose the interest to the handling editor, where a competing interest exists. Editors, including the Editor-in-Chief, withdraw from handling a manuscript where they have a competing interest relating to the authors, their institution, or the subject matter, and the manuscript is reassigned.

6.4 Publication

Statements of competing interests and of funding are published with each article.

7. Research Ethics and Participant Protection

7.1 Human participants

Research involving human participants or identifiable personal data requires approval by an appropriately constituted ethics committee or institutional review board, and must comply with the professional standards applicable in the authors' field and jurisdiction. The manuscript must name the approving committee and provide the reference number, or explain why approval was not required.

7.2 Informed consent

Informed consent must be obtained from all participants and stated in the manuscript. Where participants are children, students, teachers, employees, patients, or otherwise in a dependent or unequal relationship with the researchers, the authors must explain how voluntary consent was secured, and how the possibility of pressure or detriment was minimised. Covert research or research involving deception requires explicit ethical justification.

7.3 Privacy and data protection

Participants' privacy must be protected. Identifiable information, including participant images and quotations attributable to individuals or to institutions such as named schools, must not be published without written consent. Authors are responsible for compliance with applicable data-protection law, including the GDPR where it applies.

7.4 Animals and field research

Research involving animals must comply with institutional and national standards and follow the principles of replacement, reduction, and refinement. Field research, and research involving cultural or educational artefacts, must comply with applicable legal and professional requirements.

7.5 Risk of harm

Authors must consider, and state how they have minimised, risks of harm to participants and to groups, including vulnerable learners and communities. The journal reserves the right to decline publication where the conduct of the research is judged unethical, even where ethics approval has been granted.

7.6 Reporting standards

Authors are expected to follow recognised reporting guidelines appropriate to their study design, for example CONSORT for randomised trials, PRISMA for systematic reviews, STROBE for observational studies, COREQ or SRQR for qualitative research, and ARRIVE for animal studies, and to submit the completed checklist where applicable.

7.7 Study registration

Interventional studies should be registered in a recognised public registry before data collection begins, where such a registry exists, and the registration number and registry reported in the manuscript.

8. Data Availability, Reproducibility and Materials

8.1 Data availability statement

Every article must include a data availability statement indicating one of the following:

  • the data are available in a named public repository, identified by DOI or accession number;
  • the data underlying the findings are included in the article or its supplementary files;
  • the data are available from the authors on reasonable request, subject to stated restrictions;
  • third-party data are subject to a licence or agreement obtained by the authors;
  • the data cannot be shared publicly for legal, ethical, or confidentiality reasons, with the reason stated;
  • no data are associated with the article, in the case of purely theoretical work.

8.2 Expectations

The journal encourages deposition of datasets, research instruments, coding frameworks, and analysis code in an open repository with a persistent identifier.

8.3 Limits on sharing

Data sharing is subject to the protections described in section 7.3. Identifiable personal or institutional data must be de-identified or not shared.

8.4 Third-party materials

Copyright in published questionnaires, rating scales, test instruments, figures, images, and adaptions belongs to their owners. Authors are responsible for obtaining written permission to reproduce such material and for citing it correctly. The editorial office may request documentary evidence of permission.

9. Use of Generative AI and AI-Assisted Technologies

This policy follows the COPE Position Statement on Authorship and AI Tools.

9.1 Authorship

Generative AI tools do not meet the requirements for authorship. They cannot take responsibility for the work, cannot declare competing interests, have no legal standing, and cannot hold or assign copyright. AI tools must never be listed as authors, cited as authors, or recorded in contributor taxonomies.

9.2 Permitted uses, subject to disclosure

Authors may use AI and AI-assisted tools for language editing and proofreading, to support literature searching or summarisation of sources, for coding assistance, and for data analysis, provided the use is disclosed and all outputs are verified by the authors. The disclosure must name the tool and version and describe what it was used for, placed in a dedicated statement preceding the reference list or in the acknowledgements.

9.3 Prohibited uses

AI tools may not be used to generate substantive content presented as the authors' own analysis or interpretation, to fabricate or alter data, to create or manipulate images or figures that report findings, to generate citations or quotations, or to produce a manuscript in its entirety. Suspected undisclosed use is handled under section 3.

9.4 Author responsibility

Authors remain fully responsible for the accuracy, integrity, and originality of all content, including content produced with AI assistance, and for verifying that cited sources exist and are accurately represented.

9.5 Translations

Where AI tools are used in preparing a translated article under section 5, the authors must disclose this and confirm that they have verified the translation against the original text. Undisclosed machine translation is not acceptable.

9.6 Reviewers and editors

Reviewers must not upload manuscript content into public AI tools, since manuscripts are confidential documents. Editors must not upload submitted manuscripts to public AI tools. AI tools may be used for administrative purposes, such as assessing language quality or identifying suitable reviewers, provided no confidential content is disclosed and no automated tool determines an editorial decision.

10. Corrections, Retractions and Expressions of Concern

The journal follows the COPE Retraction Guidelines.

10.1 Corrections

Where a published article contains an error, or is incomplete, but its main conclusions remain valid, the journal publishes a correction, in the form of an erratum or corrigendum, linked to and from the original article.

10.2 Retraction

Where findings are unreliable, where the work constitutes plagiarism or other research misconduct, or where there is redundant publication without proper acknowledgement, the article is retracted. A retraction notice stating the reason for retraction and who initiated it is published, freely available, and linked to and from the original article. The original article remains accessible and is watermarked as retracted; the journal does not remove published content from its website.

10.3 Expression of concern

Where an investigation is under way or inconclusive and there is reason to believe an article may not be reliable, the Editor-in-Chief may publish an expression of concern pending the outcome.

10.4 Removal in exceptional cases

Where removal is legally required, for example following a court order or in cases of defamation or invasion of privacy, the content will be removed and replaced with a notice recording that removal took place, its date, and the legal basis for it.

10.5 Responsibility

Decisions on corrections, expressions of concern, and retractions are made by the Editor-in-Chief in consultation with the handling editor and, where appropriate, the publisher. Concerns about a published article should be sent to editor@jaseweb.org.

11. Complaints and Appeals

11.1 Grounds

Authors may appeal a rejection where they believe the decision rested on a demonstrable factual misunderstanding, a procedural irregularity, or evidenced bias. Disagreement with the academic judgement of reviewers or editors is not in itself grounds for appeal.

11.2 Procedure

Appeals must be submitted in writing to the Editor-in-Chief at editor@jaseweb.org within 30 days of the decision, stating the grounds and responding to each point raised during review. Each appeal is acknowledged within five working days.

11.3 Adjudication

An appeal is considered by the Editor-in-Chief or by a designated senior editor who was not involved in the original decision, and independent advice may be sought. The outcome is communicated in writing and may be to uphold the decision, to commission further review, or to reconsider the manuscript. The decision on an appeal is final within the journal.

11.4 Complaints about conduct

Complaints concerning the conduct of editors, reviewers, or the journal, including allegations of bias or of breach of confidentiality, are investigated by the Editor-in-Chief or, where this would create a conflict of interest, by the Managing Editor. Allegations of research misconduct are handled in accordance with the COPE flowcharts.

11.5 Records

The journal maintains a record of complaints and appeals and of how they were resolved.

12. Copyright, Licensing and Permissions

12.1 Author rights

Authors retain copyright in their published work and grant the journal the right of first publication.

12.2 Original articles

Original research articles are published under the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (CC BY 4.0). This permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, and adaptation for any purpose, including commercial use, provided that appropriate credit is given to the author(s), a link to the licence is provided, and any changes made are indicated.

12.3 Translated articles

The licence applied to a translated article is determined by the licence of the original work and by the terms of the permission granted by the original publisher. Where the original work is published under a more restrictive licence, or under traditional copyright, the translated article may not be available under CC BY 4.0. The licence applicable to each article is stated on that article's page.

12.4 Third-party material

Authors are responsible for obtaining permission to reproduce copyrighted material, including text extracts, figures, tables, questionnaires, images, and adaptions, and for acknowledging the source in the manner required by the rights holder.

12.5 Self-archiving

Authors may deposit the submitted version, the accepted version, and the published version in an institutional or subject repository immediately upon publication, without embargo, provided that the journal is acknowledged as the original publisher and that the licence stated on the article is respected.

13. DOI and Indexing

13.1 DOI and metadata

Each published article is assigned a Digital Object Identifier (DOI) registered with Crossref. Article metadata and reference lists are deposited with Crossref and remain publicly available.

13.2 Indexing coverage

Details of indexing and abstracting coverage are published separately and updated as coverage changes.

14. Fees, Advertising and Editorial Independence

14.1 Fees

The journal does not charge article processing charges, submission fees, or page charges for articles invited or commissioned by the editorial board, including translated articles selected by the editorial board under section 5.2.

Submissions that are not invited, including original research articles and translated articles proposed to the editorial board by the original author(s) under section 5.2, are subject to the charges published on the journal's Article Processing Charges page.

Any introduction of, or change to, those charges will be announced at least six months in advance and will apply only to articles submitted after the announced date.

14.2 Editorial independence

Editorial decisions are made solely on the basis of scholarly merit, suitability for the journal's scope, and compliance with these policies. Owners, advertisers, sponsors, funders, and institutions have no influence over editorial decisions. The journal is published by Wiseland Press, and the Editor-in-Chief has full responsibility for, and authority over, its editorial content.

14.3 Advertising

The journal does not carry advertising.

14.4 Commercial use of the journal's name

Commercial or promotional use of the journal's name, logo, or content requires prior written permission of the editorial office.

Version 1.0 of these policies, effective from 1 October 2026. These policies are reviewed annually by the Editorial Board. Enquiries: editor@jaseweb.org.