Ethical Statements


These ethical statements apply to everyone involved in publishing in the Journal of Applied Studies in Education (JASE): authors, reviewers, editors, and the publisher. They cover manuscripts submitted to the journal and articles published by it. Procedures for peer review, licensing, and fees are set out separately in the journal’s Publication Policies.

1. Statement of Ethical Commitment ↑ Contents

1.1 Basis

The journal follows the Core Practices of the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE). Those practices cover: allegations of misconduct; authorship and contributorship; complaints and appeals; conflicts of interest; data and reproducibility; ethical oversight; intellectual property; journal management; peer review processes; and post-publication discussion and correction. The journal applies the published COPE flowcharts when handling specific cases, including suspected plagiarism, fabricated data, authorship disputes, undisclosed competing interests, image manipulation, and requests for retraction.

Where this page and the journal’s Publication Policies are silent, the applicable COPE guidance governs.

1.2 Editorial independence

Editorial decisions are made solely on the basis of scholarly merit, suitability for the journal’s scope, and compliance with these statements and the journal’s policies. Decisions are never influenced by an author’s nationality, ethnicity, gender, religion, political beliefs, institutional affiliation, or ability to pay. Owners, sponsors, funders, advertisers, and institutions have no influence over editorial decisions.

1.3 Scope and acceptance

Submission of a manuscript is taken to mean that all authors have read and accept these statements, and have complied with them. Reviewers and editors accept them as a condition of their involvement with the journal.

2. Responsibilities of Authors ↑ Contents

2.1 Originality and accurate reporting

Authors must ensure that the work is their own, that it is reported accurately and completely, and that the methods and results are described in sufficient detail to allow the work to be understood and, where appropriate, reproduced. An honest account of the research must be given; knowingly incomplete or misleading reporting is misconduct.

2.2 Authorship

Authorship must accurately reflect who did the work. Each listed author must have made a substantial intellectual contribution, approved the final version, and agreed to be accountable for it; contributors who do not meet these criteria should be acknowledged instead. Acquisition of funding, collection of data, technical support, or general supervision alone does not constitute authorship. The journal does not permit guest, gift, or ghost authorship, and does not adjudicate authorship disputes, which are referred to the authors’ institution.

2.3 Concurrent submission and prior publication

Authors must not submit the same manuscript to more than one journal at the same time, and must not submit work that has already been published in a peer-reviewed venue. Work derived from a thesis, posted as a preprint, or presented at a conference is acceptable under the conditions set out in the journal’s Publication Policies, provided it is disclosed and cited.

2.4 Permissions and third-party material

Authors must obtain written permission to reproduce any third-party material, including figures, images, tables, test instruments, questionnaires, and rating scales, and must cite it correctly. Authors are responsible for ensuring that the work does not infringe the intellectual property or privacy rights of others.

2.5 Disclosure

Authors must disclose competing interests, sources of funding, and any use of generative AI or AI-assisted technologies, as set out in sections 8 and 14. Where no competing interest exists, the manuscript must state this explicitly.

2.6 Errors in published work

Authors who discover a significant error or inaccuracy in their own published work must promptly notify the editorial office and cooperate with the journal in correcting or retracting the article. Reporting an error honestly and promptly is treated as responsible conduct.

2.7 Cooperation

Authors must cooperate with the editorial office during screening, review, and any subsequent investigation, including by providing underlying data, ethics approvals, consent documentation, and evidence of permissions on request.

3. Responsibilities of Reviewers ↑ Contents

3.1 Competence and timeliness

Reviewers should accept an invitation only where they have the expertise needed to assess the manuscript and can respond within the requested period. Reviewers who cannot complete a review, or who need more time, should inform the editorial office promptly so that an alternative reviewer can be appointed.

3.2 Confidentiality

Manuscripts are confidential documents. Reviewers must not share, discuss, cite, or publish their content before publication, must not contact the authors directly, and must not use information obtained through review for their own advantage or to disadvantage others. Reviewers must not delegate a review to a third party without the editor’s knowledge and consent.

3.3 Objectivity and respect

Reviews must be objective, constructive, and supported by reasons. Reviewers must not allow a review to be influenced by the origin of the manuscript or by the nationality, gender, religion, political beliefs, or institutional affiliation of the authors, or by commercial considerations. Hostile, derogatory, or defamatory comments are not acceptable.

3.4 Competing interests

Reviewers must decline an invitation, or disclose the interest to the handling editor, where they have a competing interest, including recent collaboration or a close personal or institutional relationship with any author, or a financial or ideological stake in the subject matter.

3.5 Impersonation and review manipulation

Impersonating another person during the review process, whether by suggesting a reviewer whose contact details the suggester controls or by submitting a review under another person’s name, is serious misconduct. Authors must not suggest reviewers with whom they have a relationship that would compromise impartiality.

3.6 Use of AI tools

Reviewers must not upload a manuscript, or any part of it, into publicly accessible generative AI tools, because this breaches confidentiality and may transfer the authors’ unpublished work to third parties. AI tools must not be used to generate a review.

4. Responsibilities of Editors ↑ Contents

4.1 Fairness and impartiality

Editors must evaluate manuscripts on their scholarly merit, without discrimination on any ground, and must ensure that review is fair, unbiased, and timely. The Editor-in-Chief is accountable for everything published in the journal.

4.2 Confidentiality

Editors must treat submitted manuscripts, the identities of reviewers, and review reports as confidential, and must not disclose or use them outside the editorial process. Editors must not use unpublished material from a submission in their own research.

4.3 Decisions

Editors must give authors a reasoned decision together with the reviewers’ reports, must be willing to justify any significant deviation from the journal’s described processes, and must not reverse a decision to accept unless serious problems are identified. Editors should be willing to publish corrections, clarifications, retractions, and apologies when needed.

4.4 Recusal

An editor must withdraw from handling a manuscript where they have a competing interest relating to the authors, their institution, or the subject matter. The manuscript is reassigned to another editor with no such interest. Editors should honour well-reasoned requests from authors that a particular person should not review their work.

4.5 Submissions by editors

Submissions by editors, editorial board members, or journal staff are handled in full by another editor, with no involvement by the author-editor, and are subject to the same review standards as any other submission.

4.6 Support and training

The journal provides guidance to editors and reviewers on expected conduct, and reviews its own processes in the light of published research on peer review and of changes in COPE guidance.

5. Responsibilities of the Publisher ↑ Contents

5.1 Editorial independence

Wiseland Press is responsible for the infrastructure of the journal and for supporting the Editor-in-Chief in maintaining editorial standards. The publisher does not interfere in editorial decisions and does not require the acceptance of any manuscript. Commercial considerations do not override intellectual or ethical standards.

5.2 Infrastructure and records

The publisher supports the maintenance of editorial records, the correction of the published record, and the investigation of complaints and allegations. Where an allegation concerns the Editor-in-Chief, the publisher ensures that the matter is handled by an independent party, normally the Managing Editor or a designated member of the Editorial Board.

6. Ethical Oversight of Research Involving Human Participants ↑ Contents

6.1 Ethics approval

Research involving human participants, or identifiable personal data, requires approval by an appropriately constituted ethics committee or institutional review board, and must comply with the professional standards applicable in the authors’ field and jurisdiction. The manuscript must name the approving committee and give the reference number, or explain why approval was not required. The journal may request documentary evidence of approval.

6.2 Informed consent

Informed consent must be obtained from all participants and stated in the manuscript. Consent must be voluntary and informed, and participants must understand that they may withdraw at any time without detriment. Covert research, or research involving deception, requires explicit ethical justification and is considered only in exceptional circumstances.

6.3 Children and dependent relationships

Educational research commonly involves children, students, teachers, and employees, who may be in a dependent or unequal relationship with the researcher. In these cases the manuscript must explain how voluntary consent was secured, how assent was obtained from children in addition to parental or guardian consent, and how any possibility of pressure, coercion, or detriment was minimised. Research with vulnerable learners or marginalised communities requires particular care.

6.4 Gatekeeper permission in institutional settings

Where research is conducted in schools, colleges, universities, or other institutions, permission from the institution or another gatekeeper does not substitute for the informed consent of individual participants. Both should normally be obtained, and the manuscript should state how each was secured.

6.5 Privacy and data protection

Participants’ privacy must be protected. Data must be stored securely, and identifiable data must be de-identified wherever possible. Authors are responsible for compliance with the data-protection law applicable in their jurisdiction, including the GDPR and comparable national legislation where it applies. Consent for publication must cover the uses made of the data in the article.

6.6 Identifiable material

Identifiable information must not be published without written consent. This includes participant names, images, audio or video recordings, and quotations attributable to individuals. Institutions, including named schools, districts, or universities, should be anonymised where identification could cause harm or breach confidentiality; where a named institution is central to the research, its consent should be obtained and stated.

6.7 Risk of harm

Authors must consider, and state how they have minimised, risks of harm to participants and to groups, including risks of psychological distress, breach of confidentiality, educational disadvantage, or stigmatisation. The journal reserves the right to decline publication where the conduct of the research is judged unethical, even where ethics approval has been granted.

6.8 Reporting standards and registration

Authors are expected to follow recognised reporting guidelines appropriate to their study design, for example CONSORT for randomised trials, PRISMA for systematic reviews, STROBE for observational studies, and COREQ or SRQR for qualitative research, submitting the completed checklist where applicable. Interventional studies should be registered in a recognised public registry before data collection begins, where such a registry exists, with the registration number reported in the manuscript.

7. Data, Materials and Reproducibility ↑ Contents

7.1 Availability statement

Every article must include a data availability statement indicating where the underlying data can be found, or explaining why they cannot be shared. The permitted formulations are set out in the journal’s Publication Policies. Data sharing is always subject to the protections described in section 6.5.

7.2 Retention and production

Authors should retain the underlying data and materials for a reasonable period after publication and must be able to produce them on reasonable request by the journal. Failure or refusal to produce data when a concern is raised may, in itself, be treated as grounds for an editorial sanction.

7.3 Third-party instruments

Copyright in published questionnaires, rating scales, and test instruments belongs to their owners. Authors must obtain written permission to reproduce or adapt such instruments and must cite them correctly. The editorial office may request documentary evidence of permission.

8. Use of Generative AI and AI-Assisted Technologies ↑ Contents

This policy follows the COPE Position Statement on Authorship and AI Tools.

8.1 No authorship

Generative AI tools do not meet the requirements for authorship. They cannot take responsibility for the work, cannot declare competing interests, have no legal standing, and cannot hold or assign copyright. AI tools must never be listed as authors, cited as authors, or recorded in contributor taxonomies.

8.2 Permitted uses, subject to disclosure

Authors may use AI and AI-assisted tools for language editing and proofreading, to support literature searching or summarisation of sources, for coding assistance, and for data analysis, provided the use is disclosed and all outputs are verified by the authors. The disclosure must name the tool and version and describe what it was used for, placed in a dedicated statement preceding the reference list or in the acknowledgements.

8.3 Prohibited uses

AI tools may not be used to generate substantive content presented as the authors’ own analysis or interpretation, to fabricate or alter data, to create or manipulate images or figures that report findings, to generate citations or quotations, or to produce a manuscript in its entirety. Suspected undisclosed use is handled under section 10.

8.4 Author responsibility

Authors remain fully responsible for the accuracy, integrity, and originality of all content, including content produced with AI assistance, and for verifying that cited sources exist and are accurately represented.

8.5 Machine translation

Where AI tools are used in preparing a translated article, the authors must disclose this and confirm that they have verified the translation against the original text. Undisclosed machine translation is not acceptable. Authors remain responsible for any error introduced by the translation.

8.6 Reviewers and editors

Reviewers and editors must not enter manuscript content, review reports, or editorial correspondence into publicly accessible generative AI tools, and must not use such tools to generate reviews or editorial decisions. AI tools may be used for administrative purposes, such as assessing language quality or identifying suitable reviewers, provided that no confidential content is disclosed and no automated tool determines an editorial decision.

9. Publication Misconduct ↑ Contents

9.1 Definition

Publication misconduct is any act that distorts the research record or the integrity of the editorial process. It applies whether or not the conduct was intended to deceive, and whether it is identified before or after publication. The journal treats allegations seriously in both cases.

9.2 Specific forms

The following are regarded as misconduct:

  • Plagiarism — reproducing another person’s text, ideas, data, images, or arguments without proper attribution, whether or not the source is published in English, including translation of another’s work presented as one’s own;
  • Text recycling — substantive reuse of the authors’ own previously published wording without citation;
  • Fabrication — inventing data, participants, or results;
  • Falsification — manipulating data, methods, or images so that the research is not accurately represented;
  • Duplicate or redundant publication — publishing substantially the same work in more than one venue without the informed consent of all editors concerned;
  • Citation manipulation — adding citations that do not support the argument, or coercing authors to cite specific work, in order to inflate citation counts;
  • Manipulation of peer review — suggesting fabricated reviewers, impersonating a suggested reviewer, or otherwise compromising the independence of review;
  • Authorship misuse — guest, gift, or ghost authorship, or the exclusion of contributors who meet the criteria for authorship;
  • Non-disclosure — failure to disclose a competing interest, a funding source, or the use of generative AI;
  • Unethical research conduct — carrying out research without required approvals, consent, or permissions.

9.3 Image and figure integrity

Images may be adjusted only where the adjustment is applied uniformly across the whole image, does not obscure or misrepresent any part of it, and is disclosed in the figure legend. Selective enhancement, deletion, splicing, or rearrangement that changes the meaning of an image is not acceptable. Where original images are requested, authors must supply them in unprocessed form.

10. Handling Allegations of Misconduct ↑ Contents

10.1 Raising a concern

Anyone may raise a concern about a submitted or published article by writing to the editorial office at editor@jaseweb.org. The message should identify the article, describe the concern as specifically as possible, and provide supporting evidence. Anonymous concerns are considered, although it may not be possible to pursue them without further information. Where the concern involves the Editor-in-Chief, it should be addressed to the Managing Editor, or to the publisher, who will arrange for independent handling.

10.2 Initial assessment

The handling editor, or the Editor-in-Chief, makes an initial assessment to determine whether the concern is sufficiently specific and credible to warrant investigation. Where it is not, the reasons are recorded. Where it is, the journal follows the relevant COPE flowchart. Consideration or publication of a manuscript may be suspended while an investigation is in progress.

10.3 Opportunity to respond

Authors are given a fair opportunity to respond to the allegation before any decision is taken, normally in writing and within a stated period. The journal may request underlying data, ethics approvals, consent documentation, or evidence of permissions at this stage.

10.4 Outcomes

Depending on the findings, the journal may: take no further action; require a correction; publish an expression of concern; reject a submitted manuscript; retract a published article; or impose a defined period during which submissions from those concerned will not be considered. Any sanction is proportionate to the finding and is notified to the authors in writing.

10.5 Referral to institutions

The journal does not itself adjudicate research misconduct at an institution. Where an allegation concerns the conduct of the underlying research, the journal refers the matter to the authors’ institution or employer, or to another competent body, and asks for an investigation. Where an institutional investigation concludes, the journal acts on its findings.

10.6 Confidentiality and good faith

Allegations are handled confidentially, and information is shared only with those who need it to resolve the matter. A concern raised in good faith is not, of itself, treated as an attack on the authors; a concern raised maliciously, or in the knowledge that it is false, may be treated as misconduct in its own right.

10.7 Records

The journal keeps a written record of each allegation, of the steps taken, and of the outcome. Editorial records are retained for five years.

11. Corrections, Retractions and Expressions of Concern ↑ Contents

The journal follows the COPE Retraction Guidelines.

11.1 Corrections

Where a published article contains an error that does not undermine its findings, the journal publishes a correction that identifies the article concerned and describes the error and the change made. Corrections are published as a separate notice and are linked to the article.

11.2 Retraction

Retraction is used where the findings are unreliable, where the work constitutes plagiarism or other misconduct, where it has been published elsewhere without proper consent, or where the research was conducted unethically. A retracted article remains available on the journal’s site, clearly marked as retracted, together with a retraction notice stating who is retracting it and the reason.

11.3 Expression of concern

Where an investigation is under way, or inconclusive, and there are indications that the findings may be unreliable, the journal may publish an expression of concern while the matter is resolved. An expression of concern is replaced by a correction or a retraction once a conclusion is reached.

11.4 Removal

Removal of an article from the published record is reserved for exceptional cases, such as where the material is defamatory, infringes the legal rights of others, is the subject of a court order, or poses a serious health or safety risk. Removal is accompanied by a public notice.

11.5 Notice and linking

Corrections, expressions of concern, and retraction notices are linked bidirectionally to the article concerned, are freely accessible, and are recorded in the article's metadata deposited with Crossref.

12. Post-Publication Discussion ↑ Contents

12.1 Raising a scholarly concern

The journal welcomes scholarly debate about articles it has published. Readers who wish to comment substantively on a published article may write to the editorial office. Comments are assessed by the handling editor and, where appropriate, published as a response linked to the original article. The journal does not accept comments that are personal, defamatory, or unrelated to the scholarly content of the article.

12.2 Responses and replies

Where a response is published, the original authors are given the opportunity to reply, normally in the same publication as the response. Post-publication discussion is not a substitute for correction or retraction where the criteria in section 11 are met.

13. Complaints and Appeals ↑ Contents

13.1 Appeals

An author may appeal an editorial decision once, in writing to the Editor-in-Chief at editor@jaseweb.org, within 30 days of the decision, stating the grounds and responding to each point raised during review. Each appeal is acknowledged within five working days. An appeal must be based on a material error of fact or process, or on evidence that the review was unfair; disagreement with the scholarly judgement of the reviewers is not, of itself, grounds for appeal.

13.2 Complaints about conduct

Complaints about the conduct of editors, reviewers, or the journal, including allegations of bias or of breach of confidentiality, are investigated by the Editor-in-Chief or, where this would create a conflict of interest, by the Managing Editor. Complaints are answered in writing.

13.3 Escalation

Where a complainant remains dissatisfied after the journal’s own procedures have been exhausted, the matter may be referred to the publisher. The journal’s procedures are intended to provide a complete route for resolving complaints before any external referral.

13.4 Records

The journal keeps a written record of each appeal and complaint, of the steps taken, and of the outcome. Records are retained for five years.

14. Conflicts of Interest and Funding ↑ Contents

14.1 Authors

All authors must disclose relationships and activities that could have influenced the work during the three years preceding submission, including financial interests such as employment, grants, honoraria, and patents, and non-financial interests such as personal relationships or ideological commitments. The role of any funder in the design and conduct of the study, and in the decision to publish, must be stated, including where the funder had no such role.

14.2 Reviewers

Reviewers must decline an invitation, or disclose the interest to the handling editor, where a competing interest exists, including recent collaboration or a close personal or institutional relationship with any author.

14.3 Editors

Editors withdraw from handling a manuscript where they have a competing interest and are subject to the same disclosure expectations as authors in respect of their own published work in the journal.

14.4 Publisher

Wiseland Press has no role in editorial decisions and derives no benefit from the acceptance of any individual article that could create a conflict with editorial standards.

14.5 Publication of statements

Statements of competing interests and of funding are published with each article. Where a competing interest comes to light after publication, the journal publishes a correction recording it.

15. Ethical Requirements for Translated Articles ↑ Contents

Translated articles are secondary publications and are subject to the following requirements in addition to those set out elsewhere on this page. These statements follow the COPE guidance on secondary publication.

15.1 Permission

Written permission to publish the English translation must be obtained from the original publisher or other copyright holder and from the original author(s), and a copy of that permission must be retained by the journal. Publication without such permission is a breach of copyright and is grounds for immediate retraction.

15.2 Peer review of the original

The original article must itself have been subject to independent peer review. Translating and republishing work that has not been peer reviewed would misrepresent its status and is not permitted.

15.3 Attribution and version of record

The original source must be fully acknowledged on the article page, including the complete citation, the DOI or URL of the original article, the name of the original publisher, and the date of original publication. The original article is the version of record and must be identified as such.

15.4 Not new primary research

A translated article is not presented as new primary research, and must not be cited as if it were. The translators, where their contribution warrants it, are credited as translators rather than as authors of the research.

15.5 Accuracy of the translation

The translation must be complete and faithful. No data may be added, removed, or reinterpreted, and any correction or erratum affecting the original article must be carried through into the translation. Where the journal arranges the translation, the original author(s) review and approve the final text before publication. Any use of machine translation or generative AI must comply with section 8.5.

15.6 Licensing

The licence applied to a translated article follows the licence of the original work and the terms of the permission granted by the original publisher, and may therefore differ from the licence applied to original articles. The licence actually applied is stated on each article page. The journal does not apply a more permissive licence to a translation than the original publisher has granted.

Version 1.0 of these statements, effective from 1 October 2026. Reviewed annually by the Editorial Board. Concerns and enquiries: editor@jaseweb.org.